The Toronto Blue Jays have had a busy offseason, making significant moves to strengthen their roster. However, their quest to become playoff contenders is still uncertain. After finishing in last place in 2024, the Blue Jays wasted no time in acquiring key free agents such as reliever Jeff Hoffman, outfielder Anthony Santander, and starting pitcher Max Scherzer. These additions have undoubtedly improved the team, but there is a sense that there is something bigger within reach.
Throughout the offseason, the Blue Jays have been linked to several superstar players, including Juan Soto, Corbin Burnes, and Roki Sasaki. Any of these additions would have instantly catapulted the Blue Jays into the playoff discussion. However, there is one more free agent who could potentially have a significant impact on the team’s success.
Pete Alonso, the longtime first baseman for the New York Mets, has been unable to secure the lucrative nine-figure deal he desires in free agency. The Blue Jays have emerged as a potential landing spot for Alonso, with rumors swirling about their interest in the power-hitting slugger. However, Bleacher Report’s Kerry Miller recently predicted that the Blue Jays’ efforts to acquire Alonso will ultimately fall short. Miller forecasts a three-year, $75 million deal for Alonso to return to the Mets, a team he has been synonymous with throughout his career.
While the Blue Jays have made a strong push to sign Alonso, history suggests that when they are mentioned as finalists for highly coveted free agents, it often indicates that the player will ultimately sign with another team. Despite the Blue Jays’ interest, Alonso’s return to the Mets has always seemed like the most likely outcome. Even after the Mets signed Jesse Winker, it still feels as though Alonso will find his way back to New York. Until he officially signs elsewhere or the Mets add a first baseman or third baseman this offseason, the speculation will continue to point towards a reunion between Alonso and the Mets.
One potential obstacle in signing Alonso is the presence of Blue Jays superstar Vladimir Guerrero Jr., who also plays first base. However, given Alonso’s offensive prowess, there is certainly a way for both players to coexist in the lineup, potentially utilizing the designated hitter role. Alonso’s impressive 226 home runs over the past six seasons would undoubtedly provide the Blue Jays with a much-needed power boost.
While there is still an opportunity for the Blue Jays to make an offer that Alonso cannot refuse, there are risks involved. If Alonso’s performance declines in his early thirties, the team could find themselves burdened by a hefty contract. Additionally, if Guerrero ends up leaving in free agency, it would be a double blow for the Blue Jays.
As the offseason progresses, it remains to be seen whether the Blue Jays can secure the services of Pete Alonso or if he will ultimately return to the Mets. Regardless of the outcome, the Blue Jays have made significant moves to bolster their roster and position themselves as contenders. Only time will tell if their efforts will pay off and lead them to a successful season.
