Bold strategy or desperate gamble: Pirates eye stellar rookies and comeback veterans to fortify the pitching lineup
The Pittsburgh Pirates are gearing up for the upcoming season with a strong foundation in their pitching rotation, anchored by standout players from previous years. However, as they look to complete their pitching lineup, the Pirates are considering a mix of promising rookies and experienced veterans to solidify their roster.
Internal Options for Pirates to fill out 2025 rotation
The Pirates have already set the stage with a solid top three in their rotation, featuring Rookie of the Year and Cy Young finalist Paul Skenes, alongside Jared Jones and Mitch Keller. Now, the focus shifts to filling the remaining two spots in the rotation to complement this formidable trio.
Currently, Bailey Falter and Johan Oviedo are slated for the final two rotation spots based on FanGraphs’ Roster Resource depth charts. Falter rebounded impressively after a shaky start to the season, showcasing a 4.16 ERA, 4.11 FIP, and 1.27 WHIP. Despite some concerns over underlying statistics, Falter’s potential shines through as he enters his age-28 campaign.
On the other hand, Oviedo faces a more complex situation following his Tommy John surgery in 2023. While his previous performance demonstrated promise, the Pirates may opt for a cautious approach given his recovery timeline. This opens the door for prospects like Bubba Chandler, whose standout performance in the minor leagues has positioned him as a top contender for a rotation spot.
Chandler’s stellar track record in 2024, coupled with his high ranking among baseball prospects, presents an enticing option for the Pirates. Although his immediate promotion to the rotation may raise eyebrows, the Pirates have shown willingness to take calculated risks with young talents, as seen with Jared Jones in the previous season.
In addition to Chandler, the Pirates have other internal options worth considering, including Thomas Harrington, Mike Burrows, and Braxton Ashcraft. While these prospects bring depth to the pitching roster, factors like injury history may influence their immediate role in the rotation. The Pirates’ strategic moves during spring training, such as exploring Caleb Ferguson’s transition to a starter role, further highlight their commitment to optimizing their pitching lineup.
Free Agents the Pirates Can Still Entertain for Rotation
Amidst the free agent market, Nick Pivetta emerges as a notable candidate for the Pirates’ rotation. Pivetta’s consistent performance in 2024, marked by impressive strikeout rates and improved walk control, presents an intriguing option for the Pirates. Despite concerns over opponents hitting him hard, indicators like xFIP and SIERA suggest untapped potential that could benefit the team.
Veteran pitchers like Lance Lynn, Andrew Heaney, and Jose Quintana offer seasoned alternatives for the Pirates to consider. Lynn’s experience and solid track record make him a valuable asset, although recent speculations point towards a bullpen role rather than a starting position. Similarly, Heaney and Quintana bring a mix of skills and experience that could complement the Pirates’ pitching staff.
Exploring versatile options like Spencer Turnbull and Jakob Junis adds depth and flexibility to the Pirates’ roster, allowing for seamless transitions between bullpen and rotation roles. While the free agent market presents intriguing possibilities, the Pirates remain strategic in their approach, evaluating each potential signing against their existing pitching depth chart.
As the Pirates navigate the final stages of assembling their pitching lineup for the 2025 season, a blend of youthful talent and seasoned veterans promises an exciting journey ahead. Balancing risk and reward, the Pirates aim to construct a rotation that not only complements their existing strengths but also sets the stage for a competitive season on the mound.
