Contract and Conversion Decision
The Giants signed Jordan Hicks to a four-year, $44 million contract with the intention of transitioning a proven relief pitcher into a starting role. Hicks, who began his career in the bullpen and showed potential as an elite closer, was tasked with assuming more demanding responsibilities on the mound. This shift required a significant adjustment in his pitching approach, including reducing his velocity to handle increased workloads.
Performance and Adjustments
Early in his career, Hicks displayed impressive attributes with a fastball that frequently reached triple digits and a highly effective sinker. Before joining the Giants, he recorded a 3.29 ERA, twelve saves, an 11.1 strikeouts-per-nine innings rate, and an ERA+ of 134. However, converting to a starter led to notable changes. Both his sinker and slider shed nearly six miles per hour, reducing the effectiveness of his once-dominant pitch. As a result, his overall balance of pitches suffered, with his key performance metrics dipping noticeably. His performance on the mound, including a 4.10 ERA and lower strikeout rate, reflects these challenges.
Recent Performance and Role Reassessment
Hicks has split time between starting and relieving, making 20 starts and nine relief appearances in his most recent season. In early spring competitions, he struggled by conceding 15 hits and eight runs in just over 12 innings while registering only eight strikeouts. These numbers have intensified the debate over whether Hicks should return permanently to a bullpen role, where his velocity might be restored, or continue as a starter despite the evident difficulties.
Future Outlook and Competition
The decision on Hicks’ role will carry significant implications for the Giants. Returning him to a relief role could allow him to reclaim his pre-conversion velocity and effectiveness. Meanwhile, promising young pitchers such as Hayden Birdsong and Carson Whisenhunt present additional competition within the rotation. The direction chosen by the team will likely hinge on Hicks’ early-season performance, which remains a critical factor in evaluating his long-term value in either role.