The Pittsburgh Steelers are preparing for a critical offseason at the quarterback position, with Russell Wilson expected to return as the starter in 2025. But the departure of current backups Justin Fields and Kyle Allen could leave the team scrambling to solidify its depth chart. Enter Carson Wentz, the former $128 million quarterback, now predicted to join Pittsburgh as Wilson’s insurance policy.
Wentz to Pittsburgh? A Logical Move
In a recent analysis, CBS Sports’ Cody Benjamin projected that the Steelers will re-sign Wilson to a two-year, $50 million deal and add Kansas City Chiefs backup Carson Wentz on a short-term contract, potentially worth around $3.3 million—a similar figure to his current deal. While Wentz’s star has dimmed since his early days with the Philadelphia Eagles, he could provide the Steelers with a reliable backup option should Wilson miss time.
A Fall from Grace: Wentz’s Journey
Once heralded as the future of the Eagles, Wentz’s career took a nosedive after injuries and inconsistency derailed his trajectory. Following his massive four-year, $128 million extension in 2019, Wentz struggled to recapture his form. Stints with the Indianapolis Colts, Washington Commanders, Los Angeles Rams, and Chiefs have seen him relegated to a backup role.
Despite his decline, Wentz remains a serviceable quarterback with experience as a starter. His arm strength, mobility, and ability to manage games make him a logical fit for a team seeking stability behind Wilson.
The Arthur Smith Factor: A Potential Revival
One of the biggest draws for Wentz in Pittsburgh could be offensive coordinator Arthur Smith, assuming he stays with the team. Smith has a reputation for rejuvenating quarterbacks’ careers, as evidenced by his work with Ryan Tannehill in Tennessee and Wilson in Pittsburgh. Playing under Smith’s system could help Wentz rediscover flashes of the player who once led the Eagles to an NFC-best 13-3 record in 2017 before a season-ending injury.
Justin Fields’ Likely Departure
The addition of Wentz would signal the end of Justin Fields’ tenure in Pittsburgh. Fields, who joined the Steelers as a backup, is expected to pursue opportunities to start elsewhere in 2025. While retaining Fields would be ideal for Pittsburgh, his aspirations for a starting role may make a return unlikely.
Why Wentz Makes Sense for Pittsburgh
Wentz would bring valuable experience to the Steelers’ quarterback room and serve as a capable backup for Wilson. Should Wilson, who turns 36 next season, face injuries or inconsistencies, Wentz could step in and keep the Steelers competitive. His familiarity with high-pressure situations and ability to manage an offense would make him a solid addition to Pittsburgh’s roster.
Steelers’ Quarterback Outlook
As Pittsburgh enters the 2025 offseason, re-signing Wilson and finding a reliable backup are top priorities. While Fields’ departure would be a loss, Wentz provides a practical solution. With Arthur Smith potentially guiding him, Wentz could stabilize the Steelers’ quarterback depth while allowing the team to focus on other areas of need.
For Wentz, joining the Steelers offers an opportunity to contribute to a playoff-caliber team and work within a system tailored to maximize his strengths. It may not be the spotlight role he once held, but it’s a chance to redefine his NFL narrative.
